Middlebury, Indiana
In the 12 months through Sep 30, 2026, 195 homes sold in Middlebury and investors bought 32% of them. A typical flip bought at $203,000 and resold at $312,450 about 186 days later.
Elkhart County · 46540
- Recorded sales, last 12 months
- 195
- Bought by investors
- 32%
- Median single-family sale
- $334,000
- Flips resold
- 10
Public records. Indiana sales disclosure filings (DLGF, via STATS Indiana), Oct 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2026.
Recent flips in Middlebury
Houses an investor bought and resold here. What they paid, what it sold for after, and how long it took. Photos are Google Street View, so some show the house before the rehab.
157 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family
- Investor paid
- $200,000 Apr 2026
- Resold for
- $215,000 Sep 2026
- Spread
- $15,000 +8%
401 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family, 1 to 10 acres
- Investor paid
- $835,000 Jul 2025
- Resold for
- $921,000 Aug 2026
- Spread
- $86,000 +10%
114 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family
- Investor paid
- $177,501 Apr 2026
- Resold for
- $215,000 Jul 2026
- Spread
- $37,499 +21%
421 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family, 1 to 10 acres
- Investor paid
- $265,000 May 2025
- Resold for
- $300,000 Jun 2026
- Spread
- $35,000 +13%
126 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family
- Investor paid
- $200,000 Jan 2026
- Resold for
- $324,900 May 2026
- Spread
- $124,900 +62%
231 days
Middlebury, 46540
Single-family
- Investor paid
- $315,000 Sep 2025
- Resold for
- $334,000 Apr 2026
- Spread
- $19,000 +6%
Spread is before rehab, holding and closing costs.
Where Middlebury trades
Single-family sales by price. The blue part of each bar is what investors bought.
By zip
Flips here: bought around $203,000, resold around $312,450, 186 days apart, across 10 houses. That spread is before rehab, holding and closing costs.
| Zip | Sales | Bought by investors | Median home |
|---|---|---|---|
| 46540 | 195 | $334,000 |
Selling or listing in Middlebury?
We buy in Middlebury. Cash, as-is, on the seller's timeline. Agents, bring us the listing that needs a cash buyer.
Running numbers on a deal here? Try the deal calculator.
As-is, cash, on your timeline.
Nearby markets
- South Bend 2,530 sales
- Elkhart 1,677 sales
- Mishawaka 891 sales
- Goshen 809 sales
- Warsaw 568 sales
- Logansport 512 sales
- Granger 458 sales
- Peru 392 sales
- Plymouth 297 sales
- Wabash 292 sales
- Osceola 266 sales
- Syracuse 256 sales
- Rochester 233 sales
- Nappanee 203 sales
- Bristol 203 sales
- North Manchester 161 sales
- Bremen 140 sales
- Pierceton 122 sales
- Leesburg 119 sales
- New Carlisle 91 sales
- Milford 90 sales
- Winona Lake 89 sales
- North Webster 83 sales
- Culver 79 sales